Red Sox Chick/Toeing the Rubber

Because you always need a backup plan

Make Some Noise(?)

A shot of the COPP board from 2006 taken by Kelly O'Connor and used with permission.

Right now I have a handful of friends who are all in Fort Myers taking in Spring Training baseball. One of those friends is Tru (someone who has contributed to this blog in the past and someone I hope to get to contribute more this year!)  He sent me a message last night that I thought was interesting:

So I’m sitting in the stands at COPP and looking at the scoreboard. I’ve seen it before and know it is not really a very good one, as it is old. I also don’t expect COPP to upgrade the thing since the Sox are moving to a new field.

But it struck me as odd that the people (whoever they are), run the board during games use images and words to try and get people to root the team on. It didn’t register at first, but it wound up making me a bit angry. This is Red Sox baseball, and although it’s only ST, the idea that people in the stands don’t know what’s going on down on the field offended me.

Now I don’t pretend to know the details of who, how, what, when and why concerning the scoreboard and how it’s decided what goes on. But it seemed to me that it was wrong… very wrong.

I remember you blogging about the new score board at Fenway, and hoping the Sox marketing team decides they’ll pass on the temptation to put up cheering like messages. But here in Ft. Myers, the Red Sox winter home they sure as hell are doing that and it bothered me.

I’ve only been to City of Palms Park for one Spring Training and that was in 2005. Being amped about actually being at Spring Training, plus the excitement of meeting people I knew online but hadn’t met in person PLUS the fact that it was the beginning of the 2004 World Championship victory tour, all means this: I have no idea if they were encouraging fans to make noise via the scoreboards at the time.  And there are people who read this blog (as well as friends of mine down in Ft Myers right now) who have been to many years of Spring Training in Fort Myers who could probably answer the question as to whether this just started this season or if it has gone on all along.  I’d be interested to find this out.  (As a note, Tru has been down there plenty of times as well. I think it is probably something you wouldn’t take much notice of normally but if there is time to focus on it you suddenly would have a “Hey, they’re telling the fans to ‘make noise’?” moment.)

I’m not sure how I feel about it.  I’ve maintained that I’m all right with the scoreboard encouraging of fans at Minor League ballparks because, well, because they’re the Minor Leagues and there is a different atmosphere (and slightly different audience) for those games.  Even in the minors, though, there are exceptions.  If you go to a PawSox game, with some exceptions (like there being mascots), the atmosphere is very much geared toward it being like a Major league game.  So I have mixed feelings.  I guess the excuse for it in Fort Myers could be that the games “don’t count” and everyone is just down there for fun.  But I share Tru’s feelings in that I’m wondering if this is just a precursor to get folks used to what is going to happen at Fenway this season with the new video boards.

Man, I hope not.

(Speaking of Spring Training…Kelly O’Connor is there and has already taken some fantastic photos that you can find here!)


March 21, 2011 - Posted by | 2011 | , , , ,


  1. My first time to Red Sox spring training I never really noticed what the messages were on the scoreboard.
    But, this year, I have been aware of the board being used to encourage cheering, making noise, clapping, etc.
    I’ve also noticed that these messages don’t generate any significant response from the fans.
    Personally, I ignore them.

    Comment by DON in VA | March 21, 2011 | Reply

  2. As soon as I saw the first line of this entry I was completely distracted while reading your entry because I really wanted to know if Kelly O was there taking her amazing pictures. I am off to her site now to check it out, thanks. (I promise I’ll come back and read this again later)

    Comment by Dawn | March 21, 2011 | Reply

  3. Honestly, I don’t know when they started to tell the crowd to make noise at COPP but it’s been at least a couple of years. I do know that the crowd doesn’t tend to respond with noise just because the scoreboard says to clap your hands.
    As anyone who has been to spring training knows, the crowd thins out greatly after the 7th inning. The noise level is much less, the players are often names you’ve never seen before and the game doesn’t count. Leave us alone and let us decide when and when not to make noise!
    Red Sox Nation does not need to be given cues on when to clap their hands.

    Comment by Brenken | March 21, 2011 | Reply

  4. I’m pretty sure this is not the first year they’ve done that at COPP. (IIRC, it’s a low-res graphic of clapping hands, but I don’t recall it being accompanied with any fake-clapping noises or music – now that I would remember.) Really it’s bugging me now that I can’t remember better because I absolutely hate the “let’s make some noise” stuff and I would find that completely annoying.

    I like to keep score at games, and it’s trickier than usual in ST, especially the college games I went to, and I’m usually busy griping about the fact that the scoreboard never has the right names. A lot of the subsitutions are not announced, and sometimes the names are misspelled or they put the wrong name there, and one game they were an inning behind the whole time. So I guess I don’t put a lot of stock into what they put up there.

    But I do remember commenting that they use the same ads and “facts” between innings every year, so I do think they’ve done the clappy hands thing in years past too. But I’m with Brenken: “Leave us alone and let us decide when and when not to make noise! Red Sox Nation does not need to be given cues on when to clap their hands.”

    Comment by Kristen | March 21, 2011 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: